
The questions a specialist asks
A new technology is judged on its evidence and on how clearly it states its limits.
Performance and measurement
Doesn’t shading between the facets cancel out the gain?
It is the leading cause of failure in three-dimensional photovoltaics, and it is the very reason for the SHAVAS geometry. The simulation that establishes the gain calculates shading and production facet by facet: the range of 1.4 to 1.8 is net of shading.
The reference is a horizontal flat module. What about compared with a tilted module?
The simulations compare the module with a horizontal flat reference, as the tool used does not handle the tilted configuration. The module’s advantage lies in its ability to capture more diffuse radiation, which arrives from all directions: logically, it is retained when both modules are tilted. The laboratory’s conclusion points the same way: the comparison between a tilted SHAVAS module and a tilted reference “could also lead to similar gains,” and it says it is “very confident” that, for a north-facing tilt, the gains would be greater than those obtained flat. Measurement will quantify this result.
And compared with bifacial modules and solar trackers?
Bifacial modules and trackers optimize the flat module. SHAVAS harnesses the share of radiation they leave aside.
- A different resource. Bifacial modules recover radiation reflected by the ground, trackers recover direct radiation. The relief targets diffuse radiation, which accounts for 36 to 51% of annual solar energy depending on the region.
- A different order of magnitude. The gains of bifacial modules and trackers are known and capped: 2 to 10% for the former, 15 to 20% for the latter. The established gain for SHAVAS is 40 to 80%.
- The ground rather than the module. A tracker increases the output of each module, but it requires wider spacing between rows and cannot be installed on rooftops. SHAVAS increases the output of each square meter of footprint, with no moving parts, on rooftops as well as on the ground.
- Where trackers contribute least. Under overcast skies, in winter and at high latitudes, there is little direct radiation to track. It is in these conditions that the relative gain of SHAVAS is highest.
| Criterion | SHAVAS module | Bifacial module | Single-axis tracker |
|---|---|---|---|
| Additional radiation harvested | Diffuse | Ground-reflected | Direct |
| Energy gain | 40 to 80% | 2 to 10% | 15 to 20% |
| Moving parts | No | No | Yes |
| Rooftops | Yes | Limited | No |
| Maturity | Prototype, measurements in progress | Market standard | Standard for ground-mounted plants |
The measurement references differ: bifacial modules and trackers are compared with a tilted flat module, SHAVAS with a horizontal flat module. The laboratory considers that the comparison in a tilted configuration “could also lead to similar gains”; the measurement campaign will quantify this. Source for bifacial modules and trackers: International Energy Agency (IEA), PVPS program, Task 13, “Best Practices for the Optimization of Bifacial Photovoltaic Tracking Systems”, report IEA-PVPS T13-26:2024, August 2024, ISBN 978-3-907281-62-8 (PDF, 20 MB).
Doesn’t one shaded facet penalize all the others?
It would with facets connected in series. The SHAVAS circuit is designed to avoid this: the facets are connected in parallel, so that a less illuminated facet does not limit the others. This circuit is covered by a complementary patent; its final design will be settled together with the panel format.
Design and qualification
More active surface, so more cells?
Yes. The relief carries around five times more active material than a flat panel, and the panel costs more: about 2.3 times as much. The economic calculation takes this into account: it is the cost per kilowatt-hour that falls as soon as the gain exceeds 1.5. Thin-film perovskite deposition is the route being studied to reduce this cost premium further.
Doesn’t the relief heat up more than a flat panel?
Our internal tests indicate the opposite: the raised facets reached a lower temperature than the same facets laid flat. This result has yet to be confirmed by third parties. Temperature will be recorded by thermography on the measurement consolidation prototype, against its flat reference.
Dust, rain, snow, hail, wind: how does a three-dimensional relief hold up?
The relief is not exposed. It is protected under flat glass: the finished panel presents the same face as a conventional panel, and is installed and cleaned the same way. Its mechanical strength will be verified during qualification to IEC standards.
Standards are written for flat panels. How do you qualify a three-dimensional panel?
As the industry did for bifacial panels: through an adapted characterization method, with a test plan agreed with a certification body. The IEC 61215 and 61730 design and safety standards remain the target.
End of life and carbon
And end-of-life recycling?
The SHAVAS panel uses the same photovoltaic materials as a flat panel. Its recycling will therefore be similar to that of a conventional panel.
And the carbon footprint?
The module uses the same materials as a flat panel, in larger quantities. With silicon, its manufacturing footprint is therefore higher; it is measured against higher output and a smaller ground footprint, with less structure and cabling per kilowatt-hour. The thin-film perovskite route sharply reduces the material and energy required: it is this route that carries the project’s carbon objective. A life cycle assessment will be carried out using data from the pilot line.
No question matches this search. Write to us: contact@shavas.eu
When geometry becomes a source of energy
A conventional module presents a single flat surface to incoming radiation. The SHAVAS module, with its hexagonal base, forms a crown open to the sky.