Non-binding visualization

Comparison

The SHAVAS module and the flat panel, head to head.

A conventional module presents a single flat surface to incoming radiation; the SHAVAS three-dimensional relief presents twelve. Here is what that changes, depending on the time of day, the season and the site.

The table

Criterion by criterion

Comparison between the SHAVAS module and a flat panel
CriterionSHAVAS moduleFlat panel
Active surfaceTwelve facets per moduleA single face
Active material on the same footprintAround five times moreThe reference
Radiation harvestedDirect, diffuse and ground-reflected, on twelve facesDirect and diffuse, on one face
Diffuse radiation captured (simulation)1.7 to 2 times1
Production over the daySpread from morning to eveningBell-shaped, centered on midday
Annual energy on the same footprint1.4 to 1.8 times1
Relative gain in winter, high latitudes (simulation)2.2 to 2.41
Appearance of the finished panelIdentical to a conventional panelConventional
Simulator

Simulate the difference, from a factory roof to an entire country

On the same ground footprint: the output of a flat-panel installation, and that of the same installation with SHAVAS panels.

Factory roof: about 2,500 m² of panels.

Flat panels
SHAVAS

Order of magnitude, non-binding, on the same ground footprint. SHAVAS gain: the established range of 1.4 to 1.8 times, applied to each month; the measurement consolidation prototype will refine the value. Detailed laboratory results in the data room.

Flat-panel production is calculated by PVGIS for an optimal tilt. The SHAVAS gain was established against a horizontal flat panel; its value against a tilted panel will be specified by the measurement campaign.

  • Flat-panel production: PVGIS, European Commission Joint Research Centre (south-facing, optimal tilt, 14% losses).
  • All of France: 32.9 TWh generated by solar in 2025, 2025 electricity report by RTE (the French transmission system operator).
  • Default price: €61/MWh, average spot price of electricity in France in 2025, RTE.

Artist’s impression

By weather and time of day

The gain varies with the sun

The higher the share of diffuse radiation and the lower the sun, the greater the relative gain.

Overcast sky, winter

Maximum relative gain. In simulation, in January: 1.8 to 2.0 in Lyon, 1.9 to 2.1 in Minsk and 2.2 to 2.4 in Oslo, depending on ground reflection.

Morning and evening, low sun

Radiation strikes the facets at close to normal incidence, whereas it reaches a flat panel at low-angle (grazing) incidence. The optical study indicates better capture at grazing incidence; the production window lengthens by about 45 minutes at the start and end of the day, according to the working assumption adopted.

Full summer sun, at midday

Under direct radiation, the module at least matches the flat panel. It is at sunny sites, in summer, that the absolute gain is highest.

Reflective ground

Snow, light-colored ground: the relief also makes use of light reflected by the ground. In simulation, the annual gain reaches 1.53 to 1.80 with light-colored ground.

Over the year, by site

Annual energy gain on the same footprint, from 1.36 to 1.80 depending on the site and ground reflection.

Simulation over five sites and four seasons, extrapolated to the full year. For each site, the range runs from ordinary ground (albedo 0.2) to light-colored ground (albedo 0.5). Reference: horizontal flat module with the same footprint.

Compared with bifacial modules and trackers

A different resource, a different order of magnitude

Bifacial modules and trackers optimize the flat module. SHAVAS harnesses the share of radiation they leave aside.

CriterionSHAVAS moduleBifacial moduleSingle-axis tracker
Additional radiation harvestedDiffuseGround-reflectedDirect
Energy gain40 to 80%2 to 10%15 to 20%
Moving partsNoNoYes
RooftopsYesLimitedNo
MaturityPrototype, measurements in progressMarket standardStandard for ground-mounted plants

The ground rather than the module

A tracker increases the output of each module, but it requires wider spacing between rows and cannot be installed on rooftops. SHAVAS increases the output of each square meter of footprint, with no moving parts, on rooftops as well as on the ground.

Where trackers contribute least

Under overcast skies, in winter and at high latitudes, there is little direct radiation to track. It is in these conditions that the relative gain of SHAVAS is highest.

The measurement references differ: bifacial modules and trackers are compared with a tilted flat module, SHAVAS with a horizontal flat module. The laboratory considers that the comparison in a tilted configuration “could also lead to similar gains”; the measurement campaign will quantify this. Source for bifacial modules and trackers: International Energy Agency (IEA), PVPS program, Task 13, “Best Practices for the Optimization of Bifacial Photovoltaic Tracking Systems”, report IEA-PVPS T13-26:2024, August 2024, ISBN 978-3-907281-62-8 (PDF, 20 MB).

Non-binding visualization of the SHAVAS panel

The cost per kilowatt-hour

A more expensive panel, a cheaper kilowatt-hour

An energy producer’s deciding criterion is the cost per kilowatt-hour produced, not the price of the module.

× 2.3

Module cost with silicon cells (estimate, to be confirmed by quotation).

× 1.5

Plant investment: modules account for about one third of it. Land, structures, cabling and grid connection change little on the same footprint.

× 1.8

Energy produced, at the top of the established range.

Up to 17% less per kilowatt-hour

The break-even point lies at a gain of 1.5. Below it, the kilowatt-hour is slightly more expensive with silicon; above it, each additional tenth of gain reduces its cost.

Perovskite, whose active material costs 50 to 75% less, lowers this threshold. With the target cost premium set by the engineering firm for this technology, the same model gives up to a 25% reduction in the cost per kilowatt-hour. Detailed assumptions and calculations in the data room.

Cost per kilowatt-hour by production gain Flat panel = 100. At a gain of 1.4: plus 6%. At a gain of 1.5: break-even point. At a gain of 1.8: minus 17%. ESTABLISHED GAIN Flat panel = 100 1.0 1.4 1.5 1.8 2.0 Production gain on the same footprint +6% Break-even −17%

Cost per kilowatt-hour of a ground-mounted solar plant by production gain. Estimate based on a panel cost premium of 2.3 times with silicon cells, to be confirmed by quotation.

Go further

The studies behind these figures

Simulation reports, real-world measurements and optical studies can be consulted in the data room, after signing a non-disclosure agreement (NDA).